Skip to main content

Bloomberg's "Jewish State": bad idea for Israel, Palestine, and the Mideast

Reaction to Bloomberg's paper “Israel Palestine still can find way to divide into two states,” Tri-City Herald, January 9, 2014, page A-7.

Bloomberg needs to help us change the conversation.

In his guest editorial to "The Tri City Herald" he states: “It ought not to be a big deal for Palestinian leaders to acknowledge that Israel is Jewish State.”

What a disgusting idea.

Changing the conversation

Inciting racism and religious bigotry will not accomplish stability or peace. And make no mistake, declaring Israel a "Jewish State" institutionalizes both of the above.

There is (as if nobody has noticed), a difference between, say, a Jewish homeland and a Jewish State.

Israel is not a Jewish state now, nor will it ever be. Israel is a modern, secular state, with religious and non-religious people: liberal Jews, Orthodox Jews, Baha'i, atheists, Muslims, Christians and other, and yes, Palestinians.

A nation governed by one religion or race is not, and can never be, a free country: No purely Catholic, Protestant, Muslim, Hindu or Atheistic states for me, thanks.

By definition, a “Jewish State,” is one based on racism and religious bigotry. (The term "Jew" defines people of a particular ancestry and religious faith.) 

We should not expect those living in the Middle East to create a mini-American system, but until Palestinians and Jews can invent their own version of a “Land of the Free,” all treaties are but paths to oppression, political unrest and probably war --  not peace.

Bloomberg's opinion piece missed the mark this time: It is well past time to change the conversation.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

VENEZUELA'S DEMISE: INEVITABLE COLLAPSE OF SOCIALISM, CAPITALIST COUP, OR SOMETHING ELSE?

DRAFT, WRITING IN PROGRESS, OPINION
Was the demise of Venezuela's government the inevitable result of socialism, the collapse of oil prices, a coup, or something else?

We are being told all the time that the nation's collapse is because socialism is bad  (very bad), and that capitalism is good (very good) and will fix it.. I don't believe it.

8 Facts About the Circle of Fifths that you May Not Already Know

WHY I AM NOT A DEMOCRAT (or a Republican)

Blue Woman Monster, Red Male Monster 
(Between them, they bathe the world in its own blood.)

I am a Green.
Give us Greens a forum, a platform to speak from, and will beat you fair and square. I am speaking to the Democratic Party of the United States. joined at the hip to the Republican party, and the need for a new consensus. This was originally a reaction to an article regarding AOC, entitled, "Sunrise Movement takes Green New Deal to a new level." Happy nightmares.